Pinch Points In Fiction Writing

A few people have recently asked me what Pinch Points are, which made me wonder if others are struggling with what they are and how to use them. After a quick Google search I realized there isn’t really much written on the subject, oddly enough. And they are crucial milestones in fiction writing because they show the face of evil in its purest form. The Pinch Points demonstrate what your hero is up against, what causes him/her to jolt straight up in bed, the bogey man in the nightmare.

“We need to see that antagonist form in its purest, most dangerous and intimidating form. Or if it isn’t dangerous then at least we need to feel it for ourselves.” — Larry Brooks

“An example, or a reminder, of the nature and implications of the antagonist force, that is not filtered by the hero’s experience.” — Larry Brooks, Story Engineering

60 WAYS TO MURDER...

Two pinch points in every story

The main difference between them is the placement. The First Pinch Point comes midway between the First Plot Point and the Midpoint. Since the First Plot Point comes at 20%-25% into the book and the Midpoint comes at 50%, then the First Pinch Point would come at the 3/8th mark, or approximately 37.5%.

With the First Pinch Point the reader needs to see the antagonist form for herself and not merely hear it referenced or discussed. She needs to experience it, either through the hero’s eyes or through the antagonist himself. In crime fiction this can be a murderer planning his next kill or stalking his next victim. Or a kidnapper beating his captor, and enjoying every minute of it. Or even playing the captor’s recorded screams over the phone for the hero.

The simpler and more direct the pinch point the better. The important thing to remember is that the reader must feel it. Even if you choose to use a cutaway scene of the evil the protagonist is facing then you’ve fulfilled the need of the First Pinch Point.

Anyone who’s ever read a James Patterson thriller has seen these many times in all their glory. They stick right out because he uses short chapters that show what the antagonist is doing — planning, scheming, killing. Make no mistake, he knows exactly where to place them to keep the reader flipping pages.

The Second Pinch Point should appear between the Midpoint and the Second Plot Point. Regardless of whether you use a three or four act structure the Second Pinch Point should appear around 5/8th mark, or 62.5%.

This time you need an entire scene devoted to it, whereas with the First Pinch Point you don’t. A pinch point is a demonstration of the nature, power, and very essence of the antagonist force. And now, it’s more frightening then ever. Because at the Midpoint shift your character changes from wanderer — where he or she is trying and failing — to a real hero attacking the problem head on. Your antagonist force will also up his game. And the Second Pinch Point is the time to show just how evil he really is.

The Second Pinch Point could be a discussion between one character and another reminding the reader of what he or she is up against, even if the antagonist force is within your hero, depending on your story.

I love this analogy in Story Engineering…

“The First Plot Point, Midpoint, and Second Plot Point are your big meals. Don’t skip them if your goal is to add dramatic tension and jack the pace to your story. The Pinch Points are like nutritious snacks between those meals — mid-morning and mid-afternoon. They’re good things. They give you energy, they nurture you. You wouldn’t eat them too soon after a big meal, nor would you eat them right before a major meal. No, they’re right smack in the middle of the gaps between those meals. As for any other snacks (moments in which your bad guy does his thing), well, remember that in this analogy you’re trying to gain weight… so go for it. The more calories you stuff down the reader’s throat the better.”

As writers we often concern ourselves with the hook and the big twist ending, perhaps even the Midpoint. Without well-placed pinch points, though, the story will lose its sense of rising action and tension.

PERFECT-PREY

For example, in Silence of the Lambs the First Pinch Point comes when Hannibal Lecter gives Clarice the location of a storage facility where she finds a jarred head of one of Buffalo Bill’s victims. In their twisted relationship this is akin to him giving her a dozen long-stemmed red roses. The Second Pinch Point comes when Hannibal gives her the map of Buffalo Bill’s murders, which ultimately helps her break the case and find the killer.

 

Let’s have a little fun and tell me what the first pinch point is in your story, or an example in your favorite book. Leave it in the comments below.

In my novel, MARRED, the First Pinch Point comes when a serial killer whose responsible for a string of murders calls Sage and tells her he has her twin sister Chloe and if she doesn’t obey, he’ll kill her, mar her like he did to the others — eyes and mouth X’d out with black wire, erased from their ghostly-pale face.

Your turn. Go!

If you haven’t received your FREE copy of 50 Ways To Murder Your Fictional Characters you can sample what’s inside here or go straight to sign-up page here.

About Sue Coletta

Member of Mystery Writers of America, Sisters in Crime, and International Thriller Writers, Sue Coletta is the bestselling, award-winning author of psychological thrillers and mysteries. Sue’s short stories and flash fiction have appeared in OOTG Flash Fiction Offensive magazine and numerous anthologies, and her forensic articles have appeared in InSinC Quarterly.

In 2017, Feedspot awarded her Murder Blog as one of the Top 50 Crime Blogs on the net. Sue’s the communications manager for Forensic Science and the Serial Killer Project, and co-hosts the radio show “Partners in Crime” on Writestream Radio Network. As a way to help fellow crime writers, Sue created a team of crime experts (detectives, coroners, police captains, etc.) and founded #ACrimeChat on Twitter. She’s also a proud member of the Kill Zone (see details in full bio — menu bar).

33 Comments

  1. Just what I was looking for! Thanks for this article Sue.

  2. Brilliant article, very interesting…..you have made me realise I have quite a bit to learn about plot structure, thank you.

  3. Pingback: How Story Structure Relates To Our Lives | Crime Fiction Writer Sue Coletta

  4. Pingback: How To Craft A One-Page Synopsis Using Story Beats | Crime Fiction Writer Sue Coletta

  5. This is a great article. Do you mind if I feature it on my main blog, http://www.ryanlanz.com ? It has about 6,100 followers. I would provide a bio, credit, and a link back to your blog. Let me know! : )

    -Ryan

  6. Reblogged this on Facets of a Muse and commented:
    Never consciously thought about this before, but it’s a great reminder. Thanks, Sue! BTW, she has a great blog for mystery/crime/thriller writers.

  7. Wonderful advice, Margot! I will be sure to use this in my second book!

  8. Reblogged this on Entertaining Stories and commented:
    Sue has an awesome writing lesson for everyone today. I’m really swamped right now, and will reblog some things over the next few days. I’ll be back with a vengeance soon.

  9. I think I may have been doing this without conscious thought. In Will O’ the Wisp, the first pinch point is when Patty’s uncle get’s bludgeoned to death.

  10. I think you have such an important point here, Sue. The reader really needs to understand what the protagonist is up against in a story, especially a thriller. And in my experience, it doesn’t need to be an ugly, brutal moment (unless that’s the sort of story one’s writing). But it does need to draw the reader in and expose her or him to just what sort of antagonist the protagonist is facing. You’ve laid it all out really helpfully here.

    • Thank you, Margot! You’ve made a really good point. With a love story, say, a pinch point could be as simple as a quick scene showing a lover in another man’s bed. Thanks for pointing this out.

Comments are closed

  • Follow me on Amazon (click image of books)

    Books by Sue Coletta